North Fork Homes Greenport · Southold · Orient

New Suffolk Homes for Sale

Four streets, a harbour, and the first submarine base in America.

On the market
3
Median asking price
$1,525,000
Range
$899,000 $10,250,000
Typical time listed
52 days

School districts: Mattituck-Cutchogue, Southold

New Suffolk is about as small as a hamlet gets and still have a post office. It sits at the end of its own road on Cutchogue Harbor, looking across at Robins Island, with a public beach at the foot of the main street and very little else — which is precisely why the people who own here do not sell.

It has a genuine claim to fame: the United States Navy based its first submarine squadron here in 1899, at the end of what is now First Street. Expect a handful of listings at most; when something does come up in New Suffolk it is usually gone quickly and it is usually expensive for what it is.

Where these New Suffolk properties are

Every property on this page, pinned. Click a pin for the details.

Looking in New Suffolk?

A good deal of what sells on the North Fork never reaches the open market. Tell us the town, the budget and the must-haves, and we will tell you what is actually out there — including the listings that have not been advertised yet.

Or just call 631-757-1000